Jamie Dixon: Really? So, We're Having This Discussion?
The anti-Jamie Dixon talk is usually reserved for one of two occasions:
1. After Pitt takes an early bow in the NCAA's, which is more often than not
2. While he's rumored to take another job
But this? We usually don't see this type of talk in the middle of the year. Alas, that's what three losses in a row in games you're expected to win will do.
Pittsburgh, like most towns with pro or major college sports teams, loves to go after head coaches. Bill Cowher got several doses before he won a Super Bowl and in the season immediately following. On a closer level, Walt Harris won 25 games in three seasons, giving Pitt its most success in like 20 years and was never really embraced. Then Dave Wannstedt outdid him, winning 27 over three and he didn't even get to choose to leave like Harris did.
And now we're at Dixon.
Look, anyone even remotely suggesting Dixon should be gone or isn't even a great coach is probably due for a check-up at their local psychiatric ward.
Fact: Jamie Dixon has never missed the NCAAs
Fact: Jamie Dixon has never won fewer than 20 games
Fact: Jamie Dixon has reached the Sweet 16 four times in eight years
Now, I'm as impatient as anyone - ask my wife who's forced to suffer with my wild technology obsessions and needing the latest/greatest thing right away. So when people bring up the fact that Dixon hasn't yet reached a Final Four or, gasp, won a National Championship, I get it. But here's the thing that has to be kept in perspective. It takes almost everyone a while to win.
It took Dean Smith 21 years to win a title at North Carolina. Krzyzewski was at Duke for 11 years before he got a ring. Jim Calhoun went 13 years without finishing on top at UConn. And it took Jim Boeheim 27 (27!) years at Syracuse before he cut down the final net. And it's not just about championships, either. Calhoun hadn't reached a Final Four before his first title and Boeheim took 11 years to get to one. It took Coach K and Dean only six years, but, well, they're Coach K and Dean.
Sure, there are coaches that do it faster, but the ones I listed are some of the best of all time. Most of the time, it just takes a while. Part of it's getting better players, part of it's learning how to coach in big games, and dude, part of it's just plain ol' luck.
You know what I think the problem fans have with Dixon really is?
For one, he's not particularly dynamic and doesn't even come off as all that affable. Seriously, tell me some of the lasting memories you have from a single thing Jamie Dixon ever did. What's the one moment that sticks out in your mind when it comes to Dixon? Sound silly? It should. But I fully believe that his lack of a strong personality makes fans apathetic when it comes to him.Another reason is that things came pretty easy for him right from the bat. There was no learning curve with him and while there was some initial shock that the train kept running at full steam after Ben Howland left, fans got into a lull with him and see him as another boring guy. The standards were high when he came in and even though he hasn't gotten through to that Final Four barrier, he's met them for the most part.
Now, as long as he's winning, everything's fine. But the minute he starts dropping just a bit, there's nothing to keep fans on his side. He hasn't been through great ups and downs here and he didn't pull Pitt out of the doldrums as a head coach. Things have always gone well under his watch and when something like this happens, frankly, I think people are just flat out confused.
The other thing that's forgotten in this tough year (keep in mind, the team is still 11-4) is that good programs have off years. North Carolina went through the Matt Doherty era within the past ten years and suffered. Syracuse went to the NIT two years in a row in 2007 and 2008. UConn missed the tournament in 2007 and went to the NIT in 2010 - the year before they won it all.
Dixon's not just good, he's great. He's the type of coach you build a program around ... even the kind you name a court after. He's already second on the school's all-time win list for coaches and if he stays for another 7-8 years, he'll likely move to first. Simply put, Dixon's not in a position to break the coaching record at Pitt, but shatter it. He broke the NCAA Division I record for most wins over his first six seasons and tied it for his first seven seasons. Forget the Pitt coaching record, Dixon could challenge some of the NCAA all-time records if he sticks around long enough.
Keep things in perspective - things aren't nearly as bad as they seem and if there were a coaching draft tomorrow, Dixon would still be a lottery pick.
Panthers Fan Confidence Poll
Last tallied on 01/04.
9 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
before the JD era
we would have been excited about being 11-4 at this point in the season. coach dixon has set the bar very high for this program and this season he is struggling to live up to the expectations HE created. granted this season has not gone as well as we would have hoped to this point and no one is above fair criticism but if anyone really thinks we’d be better off without JD you not only need your fanhood questioned but your head examined. haters gonna hate i guess but for me it’s let’s go pitt.
Go easy
Although there will be more tough loses to bare in our near future and we might need to expect that based on our performance thus far, I really hope this negative talk about JD goes away right quick. We have, arguably the best arena in the country and one of the best coaches in the country. As someone said above, down years happen to all teams. I cringe to think some of this talk getting back to JD and to have him remotely consider the thought of coaching elsewhere in the future. We don’t need another coaching problem like with the football team. We need stability, which we have had for awhile now, and even better recruiting. It will happen. Be patient Pitt fans!
by Heinz57steelerfan on Jan 4, 2012 10:32 PM EST via mobile reply actions
Pitt fans and patience?
Never
Cardiac Hill contributor
by oaklandzoo12 on Jan 4, 2012 10:53 PM EST up reply actions
Agree with everything said
Coach Dixon is tremendous. Don’t let a one game tournament in March get to you. To be honest, you can’t really judge a program based on March, because it is just that: a one game tournament. Anybody can beat anybody in the sport of college basketball in just one game. About 80% of the time, the best team does NOT win the NCAA tournament (if you go by the average draft pick). The regular season is a better indicator of a team’s strength. Unfortunately, in college basketball, March is what gets the most attention.
Group think is usually wrong
Welcome to the world of illusions about Pitt sports. Hey, I get it. To remain a fan of our
beloved Panthers’ programs, you’ve got to be able to suspend belief. Otherwise, you’d be stark raving mad…or (gasp) a West Virginia fan….
Dixon is great. He had his best squad his first season that won 35 games but didn’t make the Elite 8. He had his other top squad in 2008-09 that fell short of the Final Four.
That said, he is probably the most over-rated coach in college basketball, he chokes in big games that are not conference games, and, be honest here people, he has an iffy at best record coaching elite talent.
I feel no need to defend the pathetic job he is doing this year. And, please, we laugh at teams that feed on the type of cream puffs Pitt lined up against this year to produce that gaudy 11-4 record.
Dixon looks bored. I sure as hell am with his team. Worst of all his team is regressing, getting worse.
Tonight we have a BIG MUST WIN game against…choke…DePaul…yea, let’s nominate Dixon for coach of the year.
I love Dixon, but let's stop Godding him up.
Why is he beyond being questioned? Let’s not make him Dean Smith. Dixon is a good coach, not great. No one wants him gone, but he isn’t above being criticized.
If he’s great what does that make Tom Crean, Jay Wright, Bob Huggins, John Thompson III, Shaka Smart & Brad Stevens.
He’s good, but not great. He can be great, but he’s not there yet. Personality has nothing to do with it.
https://twitter.com/8sTEOC
http://TheEssentialsOfCool.com/
by 8thlight on Jan 5, 2012 8:55 AM EST via mobile reply actions
Criticism
We can disagree about good/great until we’re blue in the face. That probably is because our definitions of each may be entirely different.
But one thing I’ll vehemently disagree on is that he is beyond being questioned. That simply doesn’t happen at this blog and I’ve taken Dixon to task lots of times.
I did it when he let USC rumors carry on.
Then again when the Arizona State job came up.
I’ve even done it on his stance towards Midnight Madness.
And that’s not even including the times I’ve questioned his in-game management.
Simply put, I try to call a spade a spade as much as possible here. Dixon, like anyone else, isn’t beyond criticism. That has, and always will be, the policy – at least as long as I’m here.
The thing is, though. I’m not going to blame one bad start, or even bad season, on him. It’s not his fault a McD All-American didn’t live up to expectations. It’s not his fault another McD AA decided to head home leaving his team high and dry in the middle of the year. It’s also not his fault he lost his starting point guard (who was on a Pitt record-setting pace for assists) has been injured for the past five weeks or that his AA-candidate shooting guard hasn’t been able to hit the broad side of a barn.
When it’s time to criticize Dixon, trust me, he’ll get his fair amount. But I have a hard time blaming any of those things on him.
Manager of Cardiac Hill - SB Nation's Pitt Panthers blog
Follow us on Facebook at CardiacHill and on Twitter at @PittPantherBlog
The post I made wasn't about one season.
His handling of rumors of him leaving for other jobs is the least of my concerns.
I don’t think Dixon is a bad coach. I just think he may have reached his ceiling. He should be producing a few more players like Sam Young and not Dante Taylor.
His recruiting and/or tournament performance needs to improve in the coming years.
https://twitter.com/8sTEOC
http://TheEssentialsOfCool.com/
by 8thlight on Jan 5, 2012 11:02 PM EST via mobile up reply actions

by 










